cars news 10: 2016 Kia Sedona SX Update 4: Should You Go With the SX or SXL?

At Motor Trend, when automakers hand us keys to their new cars for a year in return for regular updates to describe what it’s like to live with over time, we get a choice of trim and options. Why then, would we choose the Sedona SX instead of the fully loaded SXL trim? I initially asked the same question but, after living with our 2016 Sedona SX for a few months and comparing trims, I think we made the right choice.

Although a few options differentiate the Sedona SX and SXL, but with the technology package added, both come equipped with auto-leveling HID headlights, High Beam Assist, a 115-volt power inverter in the cargo area, front and rear parking sensors, a multi-camera parking system, adaptive cruise control, forward collision and lane departure warning as well as a heated steering wheel. Before adding any packages, the SXL’s $3,500 price premium gets you different front and rear fascia with chrome accents and chrome door handles. It rides on 19-inch chrome wheels instead of machine-finished 18s on the SX. Inside, you get dual sunroofs, Nappa leather, a leather- and wood wrapped steering wheel, and of course, lounge seating for two in the second row.

Although the Sedona SXL’s extra goods will make the Sedona look and feel more luxurious, they’re luxuries we can do without. The SX is really all we need. Unlike lower trim levels, the SX comes with an 8-speaker Infinity soundsystem plus navigation on an 8-inch screen. It’s a huge upgrade over the infotainment system in the lower trims.

We also prefer the Slide-N-Stow and removable second row over the SXL’s fancy lounge seats that make the Sedona a seven and not eight-passenger minivan. Although we have to get by without dual sunroofs, we get the added benefit of better mileage thanks to less weight (an EPA-rated 18/25 city/highway versus the SXL’s 17/22 mpg). Smaller wheels and thicker sidewalls may also contribute to our van’s nice ride.

Because of our needs, the Sedona SX was the right choice. But if you only need to transport seven and not eight passengers, don’t mind reduced gas mileage, and your kids can’t live without Nappa leather, consider the Sedona SXL.

More on our long-term Kia Sedona SX here: